切换到宽版
  • 3539阅读
  • 12回复

[综合讨论]来聊聊闪电sworks的4iii双边功率计吗? [复制链接]

上一主题 下一主题
 
发帖
108
金钱
117
威望
12
贡献值
0
爱心值
0
只看楼主 倒序阅读 楼主  发表于: 2020-01-17
这款sworks的双边功率计是随车搭的,不然我是不会单买的。

用了2个月没什么大毛病,只是左右腿平衡数据没法看,左腿大大高于右腿,在dcrainmaker的评测下面看到有人反映同样的问题。但因为我不在意左右平衡数据,所以忍了。

2个月后,电池快用完了,数据开始乱飘起来,动不动就250+. (本人菜腿目前ftp168w) 稳定输出时,读数偏高约15%. 经常停下校准,校准结果1010,也就是正常,但读数仍然不对,不是偏高15%就是偏低10%,有时也能校准到读数正常,通常是在骑行最后一段。
于是换了左右腿的电池,问题仍然没有解决,稳定输出时偏高15%,动静大时乱飘高到250+. 关键是这些乱飘及读数异常通常出现在骑行约20分钟左右,也就是刚开始骑行时数据是对的。我怀疑是不是温度问题,但是不应该啊,刚买来时不好端端的吗?!本地温度1-16,一点也不极端啊。

码表是wahoo bolt, 应该也不是码表的问题。
但有一点很有意思,今天码表显示最高功率414,而strava显示344. 差不多是我感觉出来的15%的差别。
还有一点很诡异,闪电官网说,左右双边功率计,在连接码表时,只用连接左腿即可。然而在wahoo码表上,显示的是连接上了闪电右腿。即使我把闪电右腿的电池拆了,只装左腿电池,码表仍然显示连接的是右腿。这是bug?

以上提到的15%是自己的感觉无实验室数据,我有其他三个功率计,一个stages, 一个2inpower, 一个tacx neo, 所以对自身感觉和对应的输出还算了解。另:对以上3个功率计都非常满意,稳定可靠,省心放心。

已经被sworks功率计搞疯了,每次骑行都神经兮兮的越骑越抓狂……


我准备明天在tacx上做个对比,把结果发给车店,不行就走质保了。
关键是质保会不会换到一只更烂的

请大家来聊聊你们的sw 4iii功率计怎样,有类似问题吗,怎么解决的?谢谢!

以下是dcrainmaker下面其他倒霉闪电双边功率计用户提到的问题

左右平衡问题
I LOVE how predictable S-Works Power Cranks have been but the left / right balance makes me scratch my head a little. In the past with dual sided units, I monitored my balance for a week or two and kind of stopped looking at it since I’ve always had 49/51 or 50/50. With S-works, when I pedal with left only or right only, I still get 40%-50% readings from the pedal that’s unclipped. I’m also getting 46%-54% readings consistently on my rides. Nothing has changed. No injuries, no different bike fit. I don’t know why the discrepancy.
Despite all of that though the final number that the unit displays seems very accurate, predictable and repeatable. When I average 3-5 watts more on a climb, I get predictably faster times etc.


经常掉线问题及左右平衡问题
I purchased a new Sworks Tarmac last week and have had serious troubles with power numbers and cadence dropping out, as well as huge spikes. It’s happening about 20-30 times per ride. I’ve tried all the troubleshooting options like updating firmware, replacing batteries, factory resets (on both power cranks and Garmin head unit). lots of zero offsets. I’ve been using the Garmin Vectors for years and never had any issues with dropouts or accuracy swings like this! I’m also getting wild readings on L/R balance (for years I’ve been very close to a 50/50 rider). Compared the readouts to my TACX power meter at a consistent tempo (which is usually very reliable and within range of the Vectors) – it just shows the Specialized power cranks are doing crazy things. I think it might be a defective unit. Any help appreciated!
左右平衡问题
Hey Marcus! I’m afraid there’s no solution to the L/R balance and it’s an inherit problem with these cranks. Too many people with same issue to call it bad luck. Cranks for me still have been VERY predictable and “accurate” in relation to themselves but L/R balance has always been off. At this point I believe one of the meters is off by a margin and it’s always off by the same margin so for training purposes, it’s not a big issue.
However I have never ever experienced with cadence drop outs or spikes or anything like that. It seems like your unit is definitely faulty. You should contact the shop you bought it from (unless you bought used) or the person you bought it from to see if they can help you send it back for a warranty claim.
Good luck!


左右平衡及右脚读数偏高问题
Same “problem” here.
By joke I tested the balance yesterday by unclipping one pedal at a time. When I pedal with right leg only it reads 0%-100%, but when I pedal with left leg only it reads 95%-5% roughly.
I also tested how the two units work when not connected one another but as standalone power meters. I removed the dual sided PM from the Garmin, I disjoined the two cranks with the Specy app, then I paired the left side sensor only (by adding the ID manually into the garmin) for a couple of minutes, removed it and done the same with the other sensor.
At the end of the day the right side was reading significantly higher (I believe more than 10W out of a resistance set in the Direto of 180 or 190W).

I contacted the Specialized support to see how they react to this notification.
Keep you guys informed.

thanks
Luca



发帖
29612
金钱
82637
威望
3405
贡献值
248
爱心值
4
只看该作者 沙发  发表于: 2020-01-17
买过2个,都卖了。第一个基本是准的,第二个刚装车还没骑就出了


目前三台车都是quarq
allez是用的闪电曲柄+quarq爪盘,内心深处还是对4iii没啥信心

内容来自iPhone手机客户端

发帖
108
金钱
117
威望
12
贡献值
0
爱心值
0
只看该作者 板凳  发表于: 2020-01-17
回 光光 的帖子
光光:买过2个,都卖了。第一个基本是准的,第二个刚装车还没骑就出了[图片]
目前三台车都是quarq
allez是用的闪电曲柄+quarq爪盘,内心深处还是对4iii没啥信心 (2020-01-17 00:25) 

我也想卖了……但是165mm+死贵,在这边根本卖不掉!

新出的2inpower DM 46/30真香……
发帖
3141
金钱
2967
威望
31
贡献值
0
爱心值
-3
只看该作者 地板  发表于: 2020-01-17
不知道咋聊,帮顶

内容来自iPhone手机客户端


发帖
20889
金钱
30346
威望
225
贡献值
0
爱心值
0
只看该作者 4楼 发表于: 2020-01-17
不用功率计进来围观

内容来自Android手机客户端


发帖
3194
金钱
2626
威望
36
贡献值
0
爱心值
0
只看该作者 5楼 发表于: 2020-01-17
仰望一下大神
甘老C

发帖
7792
金钱
15047
威望
457
贡献值
0
爱心值
0
只看该作者 6楼 发表于: 2020-01-17
几十瓦的路过,不好意思用功率计

内容来自Android手机客户端


发帖
1242
金钱
1609
威望
61
贡献值
0
爱心值
0
只看该作者 7楼 发表于: 2020-01-17
贴片式的吧就不是很靠谱,一脚没锁进去踹曲柄上了都有可能影响结果

内容来自iPhone手机客户端

发帖
58
金钱
74
威望
1
贡献值
0
爱心值
0
只看该作者 8楼 发表于: 2020-01-17
选Quarq就要选Quarq的曲柄,而别选RED,后悔看光版的帖子晚了,现在是用RED曲柄的Quarq功率计,想把牙盘从50/34换成48/32的都没有办法了

发帖
4330
金钱
14219
威望
11
贡献值
0
爱心值
0
只看该作者 9楼 发表于: 2020-01-17
路过看看

发帖
29612
金钱
82637
威望
3405
贡献值
248
爱心值
4
只看该作者 10楼 发表于: 2020-01-17
fanzh1969:选Quarq就要选Quarq的曲柄,而别选RED,后悔看光版的帖子晚了,现在是用RED曲柄的Quarq功率计,想把牙盘从50/34换成48/32的都没有办法了 (2020-01-17 16:36) 

你说的是red那个隐藏盘钉问题?

其实red腿和quarq腿是完全一样的东西。就涂装不同。

区别在于quarq爪盘有2种版本,体现在电池的位置,买“歪”电池版本(官方叫nhb)的方便换盘片

内容来自iPhone手机客户端

发帖
108
金钱
117
威望
12
贡献值
0
爱心值
0
只看该作者 11楼 发表于: 2020-01-19
都是经验啊,谢谢!
我还没做测试对比,趁这几天下雨搞一搞,弄完发一贴。
发帖
58
金钱
74
威望
1
贡献值
0
爱心值
0
只看该作者 12楼 发表于: 2020-01-31
是啊,RED那个隐藏盘钉可以支持48/32的盘片吗?我看那个隐藏盘钉是反向安装的,看光版的帖子上48/32的盘片的盘钉是直接上在32T的盘片上的,那反向的隐藏钉就没有办法装了吧
本帖提到的人: @光光